Web2 Apr 2008 · Perhaps the seminal moment in the now celebrated Shirley McKie fingerprint misidentification case that has preoccupied Scotland from 1997 until the present came in 2002 when Justice Minister Jim Wallace told the press that a fingerprint identification is ‘not an exact science’ (BBC News, 2002a).Shirley McKie, an officer in the Strathclyde Police … Webby four fingerprint officers in the Scottish Criminal Records Office (“the SCRO”) of a fingerprint in a murder inquiry in 1997. They identified the print which was found at the locus of the murder as being that of Detective Constable Shirley McKie. David Asbury was tried and convicted of the murder, but his conviction was later quashed.

Shirley McKie - Wikiwand

Web3 Mar 2008 · Iain McKie. 947. Mar 03, 2008 #1. Dear Member of the Fingerprint Society, Pause for thought. I have spent the past 11 years fighting experts from the Scottish Criminal Records Office who by wrongly identifying two fingerprints in the 1997 Marion Ross murder investigation brought my daughter to the edge of suicide and condemned an innocent … Webpress that a fingerprint identification is ‘not an exact science’ (BBC News, 2002a). Shirley McKie, an officer in the Strathclyde Police Department, had been assigned to investigate the murder of Marion Ross at her home in Kilmarnock. McKie was not authorized to enter the crime scene, and she denied that she did. But four Scottish Crim- dave harmon plumbing goshen ct

The ‘Opinionization’ of Fingerprint Evidence SpringerLink

WebMcKie was suspectedto be a witness in this murder case against the accused David Asbury when evidence of her fingerprints surfaced from the crime scene. Howevershe claimsthat she had not been present at the scene of the crime. Somemonths later, her house was raided by her colleagues and she was then arrested for allegedly murdering Marion Ross. Web15 Dec 2011 · Miss McKie, a former detective constable with Strathclyde Police, was tried for perjury after insisting a fingerprint found in the home of murder victim Marion Ross in 1997 did not belong to her. Web17 Apr 2006 · In 1997, a smudged print from one of PC Shirley McKie's thumbs was found at a murder scene in Kilmarnock. When she denied it was hers, no one believed her - after all, … dave harman facebook